- Why is Buddhism the fastest growing religion in Australia?
- Darren Nelson
The answer to this inquiry is multi-layered and complex. It is a
tantalising issue because it highlights the changing spiritual landscape of Australia and
provides an insight into just how multicultural we have really become.
Cultures that were foreign to Anglo-European Australians are now being
adopted by some of them - though not without some dissenting resistance. This level of
resistance in Australian society can be seen as a litmus test, used to measure future
political and religious tolerance in this country.
The story concerning the rise of Buddhism in Australia is a compelling
tale of a resilient religion that has survived despite the odds. How is it possible for a
2,500-year-old philosophy, which began five hundred years before Christianity and one
thousand years before the Muslim faith, to be relevant to modern life in Australia?
Considering all the other ancient religions that have faded from contemporary practice,
such as the sun worshippers of Ancient Egypt, the human sacrifices of the South American
Mayans and the Druids from the Dark Ages of England, Buddhism has outlasted them all.
It does not preach the dogma of a strange cult, nor seek converts with
evangelistic fervour. Those Australians who actively convert to Buddhism do so
voluntarily, and are usually well-educated middle-aged professionals who are attracted to
a sense of inner peace. This documentary therefore, seeks to immerse itself in the
substance of this seemingly magnetic Buddhist approach. Perhaps it will be like seeing
Australia for the first time, through ancient eyes.
It is interesting to note that in spite of the recent increase in
Buddhist numbers across Australia, Buddhism has actually played a part in Australian
history for some time. It did not just suddenly arrive in a recent wave of migrants. Some
anthropologists, in fact, have suggested that Buddhism was possibly the earliest
non-indigenous religion to reach Australia before white settlement.
Between 1405 and 1433 the Chinese Ming emperor, Cheng-Ho, sent
sixty-two large ships to explore southern Asia. Although there is evidence that several
ships from that armada landed on the Aru Islands to the north of Arnhem Land, it is not
known whether they reached the mainland.
One unproved hypothesis of Professor A.P. Elkin is that the belief of
some Northern Territory Koorie tribes in reincarnation, psychic phenomena and mental
cultivation is evidence of early contact with Buddhists. Despite certain rock paintings
that possibly depict Chinese junks weighing anchor or images of the Buddha, actual
material evidence remains to be seen.
The first documented arrival of Buddhists in Australia was in 1848
during the gold rushes, when Chinese coolie labourers were brought into the country to
work on the Victorian gold fields. These workers represented a transient population that
usually returned home within five years. It was not until 1876 that the first permanent
Buddhist community was established by Sinhalese migrants on Thursday Island. There the
ethnic Sri Lankans built the first temple in Australia, while they were employed on the
sugar cane plantations of Queensland.
From the late 1870’s onwards many Japanese Shinto Buddhists also
arrived and were active in the pearling industry across northern Australia, establishing
other Buddhist enclaves in Darwin and Broome. Buddhist cemeteries were kept and festivals
celebrated. Official government statistics compiled as part of a national census in 1891
indicate that, at the time, there were slightly more Buddhists in Australia (at 1.2%),
than there are today (at 1.1%).
Buddhist numbers would have continued to increase if the Immigration
Restriction Act of 1901 had not been introduced to combat the ‘yellow
peril’. Alfred Deakin, who was destined to be Prime Minister three times, drafted the
legislation to pacify a somewhat xenophobic Caucasian electorate. This bill later grew to
represent the more broadly implemented White Australia Policy.
For the next fifty years the benefits of mind training and meditation,
as taught by Buddhism, would be disregarded as some sort of obscure ‘eastern
mysticism’. Except for some remote surviving pockets of Buddhists (such as Broome and
Thursday Island), the religion became virtually extinct in Australia.
A small group of committed western Buddhists formed the earliest known
Buddhist organisation in Australia, The Little Circle of the Dharma, in Melbourne in 1925.
Progress was slow though, until after World War II when local enthusiasm for the White
Australia Policy began to decline. In 1951 the first Buddhist nun visited Australia.
Sister Dhammadinna, born in the USA, ordained and with thirty years experience in Sri
Lanka, came to propagate the Theravadin School of Buddhist teaching. She received
nation-wide media coverage.
Inspired by this visit, the next year the Buddhist Society of New South
Wales was formed under the presidency of Leo Berkley, a Dutch-born Sydney businessman.
This organisation is today the oldest Buddhist group in Australia. Its membership was, and
still is, compromised mainly of people from Anglo-European backgrounds.
In 1958 the Buddhist Federation of Australia was formed in order to
co-ordinate the growing Buddhist groups that had sprung up around the country in Western
Australia, South Australia, Queensland and Victoria.
The Buddhist presence in Australia had depended for the first hundred
years on lay people with only the occasional visits by ordained members of the Sangha (the
Buddhist clergy). But in the 1970’s the growing number of Buddhists created a need
for resident monks, and a new phase in Australian Buddhism began.
In 1971 the Buddhist Society of New South Wales established the Sri
Lankan monk, Somaloka, in residence at a retreat centre in the Blue Mountains west of
Sydney. This became the first monastery in Australia. A succession of monasteries
representing different aspects of Buddhism slowly became established around Australia; in
1975 at Stanmore in Sydney, in 1978 at Wisemans Ferry in country NSW and in 1984 at
Serpentine in Western Australia.
The charismatic face of Buddhism, the Dalai Lama, (who was awarded the
Noble Peace Prize in 1989 and describes himself as ‘a simple monk’), has
travelled the world constantly giving lectures and answering questions in 20,000 seat pop
concert halls. John Cleese speaks out for him in London, Henri Cartier-Bresson records his
teachings around France and Adam Yauch of the Beastie Boys pop group has even
interviewed him in Rome for Rolling Stone magazine.
In the past few years he has opened eleven Offices of Tibet, everywhere
from Canberra to Moscow and last year alone provided prefaces and forewords for roughly
thirty books. The 14th Dalai Lama, who holds the titles of Ocean of Wisdom,
Holder Of The White Lotus and Protector Of The Land Of Snows, has even served as the guest
editor of French Vogue magazine.
The three visits of the Dalai Lama to Australia in 1982, 1992 and 1996
were joyful occasions for Buddhists of all traditions, and huge crowds of Buddhists and
the general public gathered to hear him speak. On the third visit, and despite virulent
Chinese protests, the Dalai Lama met with and was photographed with the Prime Minister of
Australia, John Howard. It was now clearly evident at this stage, that Buddhism had become
a significant minority religion in Australia.
During this visit local celebrities contributed generously to
fundraising activities. For example, Kate Ceberano, Rachel Berger and Frente were
just some of the ‘star-studded cast’ to perform at the Dalai Lama Lounge Room.
They helped to raise $14,000 over three nights. Mushroom Records released a benefit album
called The Mantra Mix CD, featuring Jenny Morris, Jimmy Barnes and Johnny Diesel.
One local advertising agency, providing their services for nothing, came up with the
slogan "You missed Jesus. You missed the Buddha. Do not miss the Dalai Lama".
When was the last time such hype accompanied the visit of a religious leader?
But Australians are not alone in their sympathy towards his cause. The
issue of Tibetan oppression has come to the attention of Hollywood and with two new films
about his life in the cinematic pipeline, the Dalai Lamas’ profile has not only moved
into the mainstream, but has (much to the horror of the Chinese Government) gone global.
The first to be released, Seven Years In Tibet, tells the story
of Heinrich Harrer, a mountain climber and Nazi party member who encounters his own sense
of enlightenment after becoming the tutor to the young Dalai Lama in Tibet in the
1940’s. The film has attracted healthy attention because it stars Brad Pitt.
The other film is Kundun, directed by Martin Scorcese. This epic
tells the remarkable tale of the Dalai Lama from his point of view, from his recognition
as the reincarnated Buddha of compassion at age two until his escape to India at
twenty-four. Recently released here in Australia, it was reviewed by Channel Nines’ Sunday
program on June 14th and described as ‘the most beautiful and important
film released this year’.
Hollywood’s fascination for Buddhism extends beyond these two
screenplays, with many stars expressing interest in the religion itself. In February 1997,
the karate-kicking action star Steven Seagall was recognised by the Nyingma lineage of
Tibetan Buddhism as the reincarnation of a 15th century lama. Adam Yauch of the
Beastie Boys pop group has organised two huge benefit concerts to publicise the
plight of Tibet.
Actor Richard Gere, together with Uma Thurmans father, Richard Thurman,
has opened Tibet House in New York, published books on the subject, and meditates daily.
Other practitioners that have come to attention include Tina Turner, Harrison Ford (whose
wife Melissa Mathison wrote Kunduns script), Oliver Stone, Herbie Hancock, Courtney
Love, composer Philip Glass (who also worked on Kundun) and REM’s lead singer
Michael Stipe.
The momentum of Buddhism’s’ profile is driven by other, more
subtle reminders as well. A new make up is being advertised as Zen Blush, a new
sitcom is called Dharma and Greg, a designer fruit juice container has on its’
label "Please recycle this bottle. It deserves to be reincarnated too", and
monks star in television commercials and news items.
Such recent exposure does not take away the fact that Australians have
been quietly turning to Buddhism for some time. The statistics compiled in the 1986, 1991
and 1996 Commonwealth Government Census support the view that Buddhist numbers have been
steadily increasing. Between 1986 and 1991 the numbers of practitioners rose from 80,387
to 139,847, a growth of 74%. Due largely to the decrease in immigration numbers in recent
years the percentage growth for Buddhists slowed between 1991 and 1996 to 43%, from
139,847 to 199,812. This rate of increase is still higher than that of any other religion.
The three census surveys also indicate that of the eight Christian
denominations listed in the analysis for New South Wales only three show an increase
(Baptist, Catholic and Orthodox), while five (Anglican, Church Of Christ, Lutheran,
Presbyterian and Uniting Church) have decreased in numbers.
Does the fluctuating demographic between Buddhism and Christianity
point towards dissatisfaction with traditional Australian religious beliefs? Is Buddhism
more competitive than Christianity or is one spiritual experience simply more meaningful
than the other?
Of the 199,812 Buddhists across Australia today, approximately thirty
thousand are Anglo-European’s who have ‘crossed over’, by choice, to this
alternative philosophy. They have turned from ‘Christian sinner’ to
‘Eastern Mystic’. The slump in immigration figures from Buddhist countries is
apparently not enough to stall the continued growth in Australian Buddhism, especially now
that local support has been established. Back in 1938 a Japanese Shinto monk, noting that
it took China three centuries to adopt Buddhism from India, said introducing it in the
West would be like holding a lotus to a rock and waiting for it to take root.
When the Age of Aquarius spread across the world in the form of the
60’s alternative hippie counter-culture, there appeared to be no shortage of poets,
artists, actors, writers and musicians interested in a voyage of inner peace through
Buddhist philosophy and meditative practices. John Lennon used Buddhist mantras’ in
the lyrics of his music such as Across the Universe. Allen Ginsberg used a mantra
(Buddhist blessing) to bless the ground at Woodstock before the first fans arrived. Zen
meditation too, first embraced by the Beat poets in the 1950’s flourished across
first world nations as a healthy alternative to LSD-induced enlightenment.
More importantly the drug-fuelled 1960’s, when the Vietnam War was
at its height, feminist protestors burnt their bras and man landed on the moon, saw a
relaxation of traditional middle class values that allowed a greater versatility in public
consciousness. During this time, people had greater access and freedom to experiment with
new schools of thought (feminism, civil rights, the peace movement, alternative lifestyles
etc) without suffering as many social ramifications as in the past.
According to the Reverend Phillip Hughes, a Melbourne-based religious
researcher, "many people thought in the 1960’s that science itself was not
sufficient to really explain existence, but then they were not keen to go back to the
Judeo-Christian tradition with its holy books, miracles and so forth. Also the need for a
sense of peace has become more apparent".
Potential Buddhists are attracted to the Dharma (Buddhist teachings)
not only to take refuge from a world of chaos and confusion, but also to re-invent their
own personal sense of a meaningful spirituality in a society of high-tech consumerism,
commercialism, violence and apathy. Compared to the Christian beliefs many Anglo-European
Australians grew up with, Buddhism does not require its adherents to remain faithful to a
specific dogma.
It is not a faith. It is not technically a religion either, though when
discussing systems of worship it is easier to work with that label. It is more a
psychology and a philosophy wrapped around a moral code of mind training.
The founder of Buddhism, Siddhartha Gautama (born in 563 B.C.), turned
his back on the royal family he had been born into, to live life as a simple ascetic monk.
At the age of thirty-five he became enlightened and ‘saw things as they really
are’, having achieved a mental state of absolute egolessness, where he no longer felt
any sense of narcissism or craving.
He became the first Buddha and was quick to teach his disciples that he
was not a god, should not be revered and no rituals should be developed around his
teachings. Heaven and hell, he taught, are not external places that we travel to after we
die; they do not in fact exist. Rather, both places dwell only in the hearts of people.
People are either good or bad, pious or evil. Paradise exists within our spirit, it is
here and now, and not some destination in the after-life.
Meditation, he believed, is the process required for all adherents to
achieve Buddhahood. This is one of the main differences between Buddhism and other
religions. Practitioners are offered an ultimate goal, enlightenment itself, which is
equivalent to the level attained by the Buddha himself. He taught that everyone is capable
of achieving this, providing equality to all his followers.
This is a radical departure for born-Christians to realise when they
first start studying the principles of Buddhism. The best a faithful Christian could hope
to achieve with his devotion was entry to heaven as an angel where he is still subject to
the will of a greater being who could smite him anytime at will. The Buddha teaches his
disciples too become the same as he, which is why he is not a god. In Buddhism there is no
pecking order in the after life, because that would require the presence of an ego, which
is the Buddhists life work to gradually eliminate.
Buddhism dispenses with the notion of a Supreme Being, as does science,
and explains the origins and workings of the universe in terms of natural law. All of this
certainly exhibits a scientific spirit. The Buddha advised that we should not blindly
believe him but rather question, examine, inquire and rely on our own experience. This
scientific approach of cause and effect was not overlooked by Albert Einstein in the
1930’s:
"The religion of the future will be a cosmic religion", he
said, "it should transcend a personal God and avoid dogmas and theology. Covering
both natural and spiritual, it should be based on a religious sense arising from the
experience of all things, natural and spiritual, and a meaningful unity. Buddhism answers
this description. If there is any religion that would cope with modern scientific needs it
would be Buddhism".
While the antipodean blossoming of Buddhism seems to have gone from
strength to strength since the 1980’s, this has not always been the case. It is in
the Buddhist principle of godlessness that the journalist can find opposing and dissenting
voices to the Buddhist cause. This theological bone of contention is the main source of
friction with other religions.
On Wednesday, the 18th of January 1995, Pope John Paul II
arrived in Sydney and attended an Interfaith Gathering in the Sydney Domain.
Representatives from major religions, including Protestant, Orthodox and Coptic
Christians, Jewish and Muslim were invited to share the platform with him. Notable by its
absence was Australia’s’ third largest religion, Buddhism.
The organisers told SBS Radio that they were unaware that Buddhism was
Australia’s’ third largest religion and besides that there was no national
leader of Buddhism, so who were they to invite? The Sydney Morning Herald reported
that "somebody in the State Government had forgotten to invite the Buddhists".
This is unlikely, as the New South Wales Government is very aware of the presence of
Buddhists in this state and often invites Buddhist representatives to State functions. A
more likely explanation is that the Vicar of Rome holds Buddhism in very low esteem as is
evident from the following extract from his book, Crossing The Threshold Of Hope:
"Buddhism is in large measure an ‘atheistic’ system. We
do not free ourselves from evil through the good which comes from God; we liberate
ourselves only through detachment from the world, which is bad. The fullness of such a
detachment is not union with God, but what is called nirvana, a state of perfect
indifference with regard to the world. To save oneself means, above all, to free oneself
from evil by becoming indifferent to the world, which is the source of evil. This is the
culmination of the spiritual process. Christian mysticism is born of the Revelation of the
living God. This God opens Himself to union with man, arousing in him the capacity to be
united with Him, especially by means of the theological virtues - faith, hope and above
all, love".
Graeme Lyall, Chairman of the Buddhist Council of New South Wales,
strongly refutes the Catholic position. "The Oxford Dictionary defines
‘atheism’ as ‘disbelief in the existence of God’ ", he said,
"the Buddha is described as the teacher of ‘gods and men’, so how can
Buddhism be an atheistic system? Religious arguments often come down to the use of
religious language. We must ascertain to what we are referring to when we use the term
‘God’.
What is a ‘living God’? Anything that is living is subject to
death and decay, so why should we place ourselves in the hands of something, which, like
ourselves, is impermanent? If he is referring to the old man with a white beard who sits
in the sky taking notes in his little black book ready for the day of judgement, then he
is out of step with modern theological thinking and most other theologians.
Modern theologians, such as Paul Tillich, suggest that the term
‘God’ refers to the ‘ground of being’ - the very fact of existence. No
Buddhist would argue with this, but they may be reluctant to use the term ‘God’
to describe it".
Lay’s implication that the Pope is out of touch appears to be more
than just a knee-jerk defence, when you consider that the ranks of Catholics themselves
are split on the issue. Irish-born Father William Johnston, a Jesuit priest, spoke of his
sympathy to Buddhism when he visited Sydney in early January 1997. Here to attend the
Religion, Literature and Arts Conference at the Australian Catholic University, Father
Johnston spoke of the Christian churches need to introduce aspects of Eastern Mysticism -
such as meditation, yoga and Zen - if they want to increase numbers attending weekly
services.
"Some Catholics are very nervous about meditation but there is a
lot to learn from it and yoga and Zen", he said. "The Catholic Church has always
kept meditation very strongly in its religious orders; our problem is that we didn’t
teach it to the laity, who are now looking for it".
Father Johnston, director of the Institute of Oriental Religions at
Tokyos’ Sophia University, has lived in Japan since 1951 and believes Christianity
has become ‘too legalistic’, with ‘too many do’s and don’ts and
not enough vision and enlightenment’.
Besides the Catholic Churches’ potentially bilateral reaction to
Buddhism, local opposition to the arrival of Eastern Mysticism has also occurred in the
steel manufacturing town of Wollongong, an hours drive south of Sydney. There the Anglican
Bishop of Wollongong, the Reverend Reg Piper has weighed into the debate expressing his
annoyance not only at the presence of Buddhism, but the presence of a philosophy he sees
as evil.
The contest began when a Taiwan-based Buddhist sect, Fokuangshan,
opened a huge fifty million-dollar temple just south of the steel city in Berkley. The
monks there planned to promote their style of ‘humanistic’ Buddhism, which
emphasises the ‘oneness and co-existence of the global village’.
The Fokuangshan sect was founded in the mid-1960’s and has more
than one hundred branches world-wide (including Brisbane, Melbourne and Perth) with 1.5
million members and its own university, several schools, an organ donor bank, a retirement
home, even a cemetery. This growth is due to its’ charismatic founding father, the
Venerable Hsing Yun. The size of the Wollongong temple, called Nan Tien, is second only to
their headquarters in Taipei.
Bishop Piper’s concerns are not shared by other Christian churches
such as the local Uniting Church, which has adopted a user-friendly approach to the
temple. On Tuesday, the 18th of June 1996, Bishop Piper appeared on the
ABCs’ 7.30 Report to voice his opposition.
Bishop Piper: See when you have the bible view of humankind,
generally, if it is outside the framework of the truth - the bible terms it as evil.
Reporter: Is it a deception?.
Bishop Piper: In that respect, yes. While ever it is not based
in the truth of Christ, it would be a deception. Because Buddhism is basically an
atheistic religion. There is no god.
Reporter: Why is that a problem?.
Bishop Piper: Because God has revealed himself through Christ.
Christ has been raised from the dead. He said he is God. There is no other way to the
truth and no other way to really live except through Christ.
The growing curiosity about Buddhism has so worried Bishop Piper that
he has made a video called In Search Of Paradise - A Biblical Response To Buddhism.
It is to warn all Christians of the evil deception of Buddhism, that has arrived to
convert them.
Reverend Shin of the Nan Tien temple remains perplexed with Bishop
Pipers attitude. "We don’t convert people to Buddhism or change their
religion", he said. " As long as they feel comfortable with any of the practices
or any of the beliefs and it is good for the society, good for them and good for the
family, that is the most important thing. Whether they decide to become Buddhists or not -
that is not our concern".
Local opposition to Buddhism also extends beyond the Christian clergy.
A survey by the Federal Office Of Multicultural Affairs, conducted in 1988, found that 41%
of the general population did not wish to have a Buddhist as a workmate. Only Muslims
fared worse.
Despite this, on Sunday 8th February this year Australian
Buddhists were delighted to learn they had a friend in a high place when the
Governor-General, Sir William Deane, expressed his support at the opening of the Rahula
Community Lodge in Canberra.
"A report from the Bureau of Immigration, Multicultural and
Population Research a couple of years ago, showed that over the ten years to 1991 Buddhism
was by far the largest growing religion in our country: an increase in the order of some
300%" he said. "To a significant extent, of course, the figures reflect the
substantial increase in migration from south-east Asia over that period.
But the second largest national group were Australian-born Buddhists -
many from non-Asian cultures attracted by both the philosophy and the practice of
Buddhism, with its emphasis upon the search for inner peace and understanding. I offer my
very best wishes for the success of all that you hope to achieve in the years ahead as
future stages of the centre are completed. May all your endeavours prosper and bring joy
to those whom they are intended to help".
Buddhism continues to maintain a steady trickle of recruitment at the
grass roots level. According to the Venerable Pannyavaro, a monk based in Surry Hills in
Sydney, young people are still attracted to Buddhism because they are looking for an
alternative to established Christian churches and they can explore Buddhism without
feeling obliged to join.
"A lot of young people in the twenty to mid-thirty age group are
coming because they don’t feel imposed upon", he said, " and there are
deeper meditative techniques they can draw upon". The Buddhist website he operates
(http://www.buddhanet.net) gets an average 9,000 ‘hits’ a day. Venerable
Pannyavaro offers cyber-nirvana at this site in the form of online meditation sessions
where people can log on, meditate and contemplate the infinite.
There are now more than ninety Buddhist temples and organisations in
New South Wales, sixty-five of them in Sydney. The bulk of the two hundred people who each
week visit the Buddhist Library, Meditation and Information Centre in Camperdown in Sydney
are in the thirty to fifty age group. About eighty-percent are from a non-Asian
background.
Much to the horror of the Christian clergy (if they ever find out),
Buddhism is even being taught in one New South Wales primary school during religious
scripture classes. In early 1995 at Blackheath Primary School a group of parents
approached the principal, Kate Allan, asking the school to provide Buddhist instruction as
well as the traditional Catholic and Protestant options. Now, forty-five of the schools
three hundred and fifty students attend classes in Buddhism.
"The move came from the community", Allan says. "In the
mountains we have quite a diverse community and it was the choice of the parents to have
these classes - it was not something imposed on the whole school".
Answering the question of Buddhism's growing popularity in is clearly going to be a
rich and involved conclusion. This religion seems to have, at first glance, a vigorous
influence on the world stage. Just when you think you have examined the issues thoroughly,
you suddenly discover that you are still only looking at the tip of the iceberg.